March 25, 2003

Do We Need a Standardized RSS Specification?

James Snell wrote:

Which is better... a "real" standard or a spec everyone agrees to implement, "real" or not?

and then later on ...

"We don't need a standardized RSS specification."

I just can't believe you wrote that, James!

That's like saying we don't need WS-I because everyone is using Web Services and we can always fix any interop problems on a point-to-point basis! I believe very close to 100% of WS-I members would not agree with _that_ viewpoint.

I have nothing against an "ad-hoc" standardization and consensus building PROCESS, so long as what comes out the end is a stable and interoperable standard/specification which can be baked into real products, and which won't require changes every day/week/month.

So let me pose a specific question to James and the world at large:

Isn't it about time to propose RSS as an official Internet Standard? (as per RFC-2026)
Or is there some other organization we (the industry) should consider?

It feels to me like RSS has reached the point where we should be thinking along such lines, as RSS is rapidly becoming part of the core Internet fabric.

And yes, I do consider an RFC to qualify as a "real standard", BTW.

Entry categories: RSS Standards
Posted by Jorgen Thelin at March 25, 2003 07:58 PM - [PermaLink]
 
Traceback List
Standardized RSS
Excerpt: TheArchitect.co.uk - Jorgen Thelin's weblog: Do We Need a Standardized RSS Specification?: "So let me pose a specific question to James and the world at large: Isn't it about time
Weblog: snellspace
Tracked: March 25, 2003 10:06 PM
RSS and the RESTian Dilema
Excerpt: There we where thinking we had some agreement on the RSS format and had achieved some convergence and stability at the 2.0 level, then this happens! So, what have Don and Sam created? Is it RSS v4.0, or RSS 2.0+xhtml:body, or what? - and how exactly d...
Weblog: TheArchitect.co.uk - Jorgen Thelin's weblog
Tracked: March 30, 2003 03:48 AM
Comments
For what it's worth, I am considering including RSS in our Danish e-Government Interoperability Framework. But I can't give it "green" until it's a "real standard". Posted by: John Gøtze on March 25, 2003 10:37 PM
Update 18-April-2003: An Internet-Draft of RSS 2.0 has been produced - more details here. Posted by: Jorgen Thelin on April 18, 2003 08:27 PM